Concerns Raised Over Digital Advertising Data and National Security
/ 4 min read
Quick take - An investigation by WIRED, Bayerischer Rundfunk, and Netzpolitik.org has raised concerns about the tracking of U.S. military personnel in Germany through digital advertising data, highlighting potential national security risks associated with the unregulated data broker industry and the implications of sensitive location information being accessible to foreign entities.
Fast Facts
- An investigation by WIRED, Bayerischer Rundfunk, and Netzpolitik.org reveals U.S. companies are tracking military personnel in Germany through location data from a U.S.-based data broker.
- Key military installations, including Büchel Air Base and Ramstein Air Base, were found to have significant tracking activity, raising national security concerns.
- Senator Ron Wyden has expressed alarm over the unregulated data broker industry, which he believes poses a threat to national security, and has reached out to the Defense Department without a response.
- The investigation highlights vulnerabilities in mobile advertising IDs that, when combined with geolocation data, can expose sensitive information about military personnel.
- Legislative efforts to enhance privacy protections and address the risks posed by data brokers have stalled, emphasizing the urgent need for Congressional action.
Concerns Over Digital Advertising Data Collection and National Security
A recent investigation has raised significant concerns regarding the implications of digital advertising data collection on U.S. national security. The investigation particularly focuses on the movements of military personnel stationed in Germany and was conducted by WIRED, Bayerischer Rundfunk (BR), and Netzpolitik.org.
Tracking Military Personnel
The investigation revealed that U.S. companies are tracking the daily routines of service members through the analysis of billions of location coordinates sourced from a U.S.-based data broker. It tracked hundreds of thousands of signals from devices within sensitive U.S. military installations, including locations such as the Dagger Complex and various establishments in Wiesbaden. Key bases such as Büchel Air Base, Grafenwöhr Training Area, and Ramstein Air Base were also included in the tracking.
At Büchel Air Base, which is believed to house U.S. nuclear weapons, investigators tracked 38,474 location signals from 189 devices. Grafenwöhr Training Area recorded 191,415 signals from 1,257 devices, while Ramstein Air Base logged 164,223 signals from nearly 2,000 devices, including those from base schools.
Implications and Concerns
The implications of this data collection are profound, as it potentially allows foreign governments to identify individuals with access to sensitive areas, which could be exploited by foreign entities. Senator Ron Wyden has voiced concerns regarding the unregulated data broker industry, believing it poses a significant threat to national security. He reached out to the U.S. Defense Department concerning the tracking of service members but reportedly did not receive a response.
The investigation highlighted vulnerabilities, noting that mobile advertising IDs can unveil sensitive information when combined with geolocation data. A former contractor demonstrated how such commercially available data could be weaponized for pattern-of-life analysis, raising alarms about the risk posed by even low-level personnel who may have access to sensitive infrastructure.
Legislative and Regulatory Responses
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is reportedly preparing to file lawsuits to recognize U.S. military installations as protected sites, underscoring the urgency of the situation. Despite existing U.S. laws, the criteria and extent of protections for personal devices remain ambiguous. An internal Pentagon presentation acknowledged potential compromises to military secrets and noted that domestic data collection could constitute a force protection issue.
The investigation found that the data broker industry has been recognized as a national security threat since at least 2016, with ongoing concerns about the ease of access to sensitive information about military personnel. Recent arrests in Germany involved individuals accused of attempting to transmit sensitive information to foreign intelligence agencies, further emphasizing the potential consequences of such data exploitation.
Amid these revelations, legislative efforts to implement comprehensive privacy protections in the U.S. have stalled, with various bills failing to progress. The Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act aims to prevent the government from purchasing data that would typically require a warrant, highlighting the pressing need for Congressional action to address the threats posed by data brokers to privacy and national security. As the Pentagon remains aware of these risks, service members are urged to adhere strictly to operational security protocols to mitigate potential vulnerabilities.
Original Source: Read the Full Article Here
